PGMS vs PGE in Bakery Formulations: Why Replacing One with the Other Can Be Tricky

Nov 09, 2026 Leave a message

Changing an emulsifier in a bakery formula sounds simple enough. Keep the dosage similar, run a batch and see how it performs. But with PGMS and PGE, I wouldn't be quite so quick to make that switch.

 

Both are used in aerated bakery systems, but they don't necessarily give the same results. The difference becomes more noticeable when you look beyond the initial mixing stage.

 

PGMS (propylene glycol monostearate, commonly grouped under E477) is useful when a formulation needs good air incorporation. Think about whipped toppings, aerated shortenings and certain cream fillings. It helps develop a fine foam structure during mixing, which is important when volume and aeration are part of the product specification.

 

PGE (E475, polyglycerol esters of fatty acids) has a different role in many bakery formulations. Depending on its fatty acid composition and esterification characteristics, it can influence both aeration and the behaviour of the fat phase. This makes it worth considering in cake batters and shortening-based systems where the structure needs to hold up during further processing and baking.

 

One thing I find particularly important is what happens after mixing. A batter may have plenty of air incorporated, but that doesn't automatically mean it will retain its structure in the oven. Temperature, fat crystallisation and the interaction between the emulsifier and other ingredients all play a part.

 

This is also why some manufacturers consider using PGMS and PGE together rather than choosing just one. The idea is to balance air incorporation with the stability of the finished structure. It can work, but the ratio needs to be developed around the actual formulation.

I'd pay particular attention to the shortening used in these systems. Palm-based shortening, other vegetable fats and different melting-point grades don't behave identically. Even when the emulsifier combination stays the same, changing the fat source can produce a different aeration result.

 

So, when comparing PGMS and PGE, I wouldn't focus too much on which one is the stronger emulsifier. I'd first look at what the product needs: faster aeration, better foam retention, or a more stable structure during baking. That's a much more useful starting point for formulation work.

 

PGEvs PGMS

Zhengzhou yizeli indutr. co., ltd Social responsibility

Quality is foundation, Safety is the bottom line, Sincerity is basis. Responsibly is the key point.

Send Inquiry